Tuesday, December 4, 2012

3D is the way to go but what about 2D?

Do you remember ArchiCAD 11?

It was the version, which was focused mainly on 2D related new features.

I can remember the big debates just after the release. Some users were so upset and they felt incredibly betrayed.

Their point was, 3D is the way to go and Graphisoft should not spent time on developing the 2D features.

Well, I did not agree with them at that time and I do not agree with them today as well.

I agree with the "3D is the way to go part" but I do not agree with the rest. Here are my reasons:

Image from bdcnetwork

1- 2D is still the main form of communicating project information. Yes, we all saw these fancy pictures of site engineers playing with models using iPads. But let's be honest, it's not their main media. They still use 2D drawings and the model is just a supportive document. Will this change? Yes, but I don't know when...



2- We always need 2D input even while creating 3D Models. For instance we define the cross section of a complex profile in 2D. So it becomes very important for us how good is our modeling tool's 2D capabilities. Do we have enough methods to define an arc or a spline?


3- Clash detection is mostly considered as a coordination process between MEP and other disciplines. We all know why. MEP is usually the troublemaker of the project:) In this case, many BIM beginers believes clash detection should be in 3D. Not entirely! ArchiCAD 11's Trace Reference (a developed version of Ghost Story) has a vital role in our business. When we coordinate a project, we also check Architecture vs Architecture and Structure vs Structure by using trace reference. We compare the section generated from  our model to the design drawings etc. Believe me we normally find 10s of discrepancies within the same discipline drawings. This would not be possible with tools that provide only 3D Clash Detection Tools!

Please do not get me wrong! I am absolutely in love with the latest developments in ArchiCAD. Morph Tool saved our lives in one of our recent projects:)) I am just saying let's not ignore the relaity of 2D:))

Have a fabulous day!

Diyane Koseoglu
www.bimes.com

14 comments:

  1. And, there is SO much more that should be better in 2D work ...

    - dimensioning, especially level dimensioning
    - annotation in general (link to general notes databases)
    - PDF size
    - revision clouds/annotation
    - DFW handling

    Otherwise, ArchiCAD is in fact (and has always been!) one of the fastest drafting packages on market!!!!

    ReplyDelete
  2. it should have been DWF, of course ...

    ReplyDelete
  3. I absolutely agree on all your comments Djordje!

    ReplyDelete
  4. Your ideal sidekick in your extra time and can engage you in each and enjoy with CALL GIRLS IN DUBAI

    Whatsapp and Call Number +971561616995
    http://dubai-peaches.com/callgirlsindubai.html
    https://www.scoop.it/t/dubai-escorts-by-anjalimodel9
    https://vk.com/dubaiescorts.verified

    ReplyDelete
  5. Hi all! I am Renu, a young Indian escort. In CALL GIRLS IN DUBAI I came in order to meet people and to give them physical pleasure. Vivid sensations of free desires are similar to the taste of spices.You have good time with me – that's why I'm taking a decent pay.

    Whatsapp and Call Number +971561616995
    http://dubaiescort-verified.com/callgirlsindubai.html
    https://www.scoop.it/t/dubai-escorts-by-anjalimodel9
    https://vk.com/dubaiescorts.verified

    ReplyDelete
  6. Professional services can not be inexpensive. CALL GIRLS IN DUBAI yourself into the wonderful world that exists in bed and desire in it are infinite.

    Whatsapp and Call Number +971561616995
    http://dubaiescorts-verified.com/callgirlsindubai.html
    https://www.scoop.it/t/dubai-escorts-by-anjalimodel9
    https://vk.com/dubaiescorts.verified

    ReplyDelete
  7. CALL GIRLS IN ABU DUBAI is the most sizzling goal for remote exchange these and a huge number of individuals come here to test their

    Whatsapp and Call Number +971561616995
    http://dubaiescorts110.com/callgirlsindubai.html
    https://www.scoop.it/t/dubai-escorts-by-anjalimodel9
    https://vk.com/dubaiescorts.verified

    ReplyDelete
  8. The ladies from the escort administrations would be accessible everyday in view of the client's necessity. Dubai being the lovely city pulls in vacationers and business elements in like manner. CALL GIRLS IN ABU DUBAI give an energizing and engaging touch to the typical stale

    Whatsapp and Call Number +971561616995
    http://www.escortsdubai110.com/callgirlsindubai.html
    https://www.scoop.it/t/dubai-escorts-by-anjalimodel9
    https://vk.com/dubaiescorts.verified

    ReplyDelete
  9. From a quieting back rub to a sidekick, CALL GIRLS IN DUBAI give valuable organization to their customers. The organizations would guarantee that the young ladies are a delight to be in his organization.

    Whatsapp and Call Number +971561616995
    http://independent-escorts-girls.com/
    https://www.scoop.it/t/dubai-escorts-by-anjalimodel9
    https://vk.com/dubaiescorts.verified

    ReplyDelete
  10. They would be a much needed development for the bustling life design of people. The wonderful ladies are waiting for their customers at the CALL GIRLS IN DUBAI benefit organizations to give them great administration.

    Whatsapp and Call Number +971561616995
    http://www.dubaihighescorts.com/
    https://www.scoop.it/t/dubai-escorts-by-anjalimodel9
    https://vk.com/dubaiescorts.verified

    ReplyDelete
  11. Whatsapp and Call Number +971561616995
    http://www.escortsdubai110.com/muscatescorts.html
    https://www.scoop.it/t/dubai-escorts-by-anjalimodel9
    https://vk.com/dubaiescorts.verified

    Choosing Muscat Escorts is direct and straightforward because of the expansion in the quantity of online sites accessible. These sorts of ladies would be ideal organization for any man endeavoring to spend a remarkable night in the city.

    ReplyDelete
  12. The request of escorts is high in Muscat Escorts and there are bunches of organizations in Muscat which are working extremely well and offering the best administrations. Overall individuals come in Muscat and mess around with acclaimed and sharp escorts.

    Whatsapp and Call Number +971561616995
    http://dubaiescorts110.com/muscatescorts.html
    https://www.scoop.it/t/dubai-escorts-by-anjalimodel9
    https://vk.com/dubaiescorts.verified

    ReplyDelete
  13. Excellence closes CALL GIRLS IN ABU DUBAI. Everywhere throughout the world young ladies come in Dubai and do diverse business.

    Whatsapp and Call Number +971561616995
    http://escort19.com/
    https://www.scoop.it/t/dubai-escorts-by-anjalimodel9
    https://vk.com/dubaiescorts.verified

    ReplyDelete
  14. We are too working in CALL GIRLS IN ABU DUBAI most recent couple of years and we propelled this site as of late for you. Our group is skill in this field and we have most in vogue, strong, experienced and youthful ability. They are knowledgeable and have a place with great families. They are from various nations.
    Call and whatsapp number 00971522909500
    http://dubaimodels.co/callgirlsindubai.html
    https://www.scoop.it/t/dubai-escorts-by-anjalimodel9
    https://vk.com/dubaiescorts.verified

    ReplyDelete